Help keep the hotline alive, donate now →
The Pet Parent Hotline
The Pet Parent Hotline
The Pet Parent Hotline is for pet parents who love their pets, but feel overwhelmed by behavior problems, rising vet bills, conflicting advice, and the daily stress of trying to do right by their pets without losing themselves in the process.

If your dog has behavior issues, your cat is doing something you do not understand, your household feels chaotic, or you are worried about the cost of pet care, this podcast gives you practical pet parenting advice you can actually use. You will get real-world help with dog training challenges, cat behavior problems, vet visits, pet care costs, multi-pet household stress, and the everyday decisions that can leave even devoted pet parents exhausted.

Hosted by Amy Castro, communication expert, longtime animal rescue leader, and former veterinary assistant, The Pet Parent Hotline helps you cut through bad advice, avoid costly mistakes, and make smarter choices with more confidence.

With more than 4,000 foster pets under her care and 15+ years of rescue experience, Amy brings honest guidance that works in real life, not just in theory.

You love your pets. You should not have to live in constant stress because of them.

New episodes every week.
Nov. 22, 2026

Pets as Gifts: What People Get Wrong & How to Do It Right

Pets as Gifts: What People Get Wrong & How to Do It Right
Pets as Gifts: What People Get Wrong & How to Do It Right
The Pet Parent Hotline
Pets as Gifts: What People Get Wrong & How to Do It Right

Is giving a pet as a gift a bad idea? Whether you're considering a puppy for Christmas, a kitten for a birthday, or a dog or cat for someone you love, there's a big difference between giving someone a pet they've helped choose and surprising them with one they might not want. Shelters and rescues often warn against giving pets as gifts, but after more than 16 years in animal rescue, I think that advice misses something important. Giving a pet as a gift isn't necessarily the problem. It's how...

Key Takeaways

  • Giving a pet as a gift is not inherently wrong, but the critical mistake is confusing gifting a pet with choosing the pet for someone else.
  • Research on pets as gifts is mixed, but involving the recipient in the selection process drastically increases the chances of a successful match.
  • Surprising someone with a life-changing responsibility like a pet or a luxury car often leads to resentment if they never agreed to the commitment.
  • When bringing a pet home for children, parents must remember that the responsibility ultimately rests with the adults in the household.
  • Instead of chaotic holiday morning surprises, a controlled surprise—such as wrapping supplies and letting the recipient help choose their pet later—creates a much better experience for everyone.


Is giving a pet as a gift a bad idea? Whether you're considering a puppy for Christmas, a kitten for a birthday, or a dog or cat for someone you love, there's a big difference between giving someone a pet they've helped choose and surprising them with one they might not want.

Shelters and rescues often warn against giving pets as gifts, but after more than 16 years in animal rescue, I think that advice misses something important. Giving a pet as a gift isn't necessarily the problem. It's how the decision gets made.

In this episode of The Pet Parent Hotline, I'm challenging the conventional wisdom about pets as gifts and explaining how to make a thoughtful, responsible choice without sacrificing the excitement of a special occasion.

I'll share some personal experiences that taught me a lot about gift-giving, including the BMW my husband surprised me with that I wasn't exactly thrilled to receive, and the cat named Mingy that we gave my mother-in-law, even though she'd wanted a dog.

I'll also tell you about a Christmas morning puppy delivery we arranged through my rescue. The parents were expecting a magical moment for their child, but things didn't go quite as planned.

You'll learn:

  • Why gifting someone a pet and surprising them with one are two very different things.
  • Why involving the recipient in choosing the pet is so important for finding the right personality, energy level, and lifestyle match.
  • Why pets given to children are ultimately a family responsibility, even when they're presented as a child's special gift.
  • What to consider before bringing a puppy or kitten home on Christmas morning.
  • How to create a memorable gift through a controlled surprise, without making a life-changing decision for someone else.

We'll also take a quick look at what the limited research says about pets given as gifts and whether the evidence supports claims that shelters are flooded with unwanted Christmas puppies and kittens after the holidays.

The bottom line: A pet doesn't have to be an unexpected surprise to be a wonderful gift. Involving the recipient in choosing the pet, helping with adoption fees or supplies, or planning a special homecoming can make the experience just as meaningful, with a much better chance of finding the right match.

Before you give someone a puppy, kitten, or other pet for Christmas, a birthday, or any special occasion, listen to this episode. You might rethink what makes a truly great gift. And if you know someone who's considering giving a pet as a gift, please share this episode with them. It could make all the difference for both the person and the pet.

Resources

For more practical pet parenting advice, visit petparenthotline.com.


Stuck on a pet problem? Send it here.

Practical pet advice for busy pet parents.

Love the show? Follow The Pet Parent Hotline so you don’t miss an episode, and share this one with a pet parent who needs it.

Listen & Follow: 🌍Official Site |📱Facebook |📺YouTube | 🍏 Apple |🎵Spotify

The Pet Parent Hotline covers real-world dog and cat behavior, training, pet health and nutrition, veterinary decisions, pet-care costs, aging pets, and everyday life with animals.

No fluff. No guilt. Just useful advice to help you make smarter decisions and enjoy life with your pets.

Help us reach more pet parents like you: A 5-star rating or review on Apple Podcasts helps new listeners feel confident trying us out.

Contact: Amy@petparenthotline.com
©Ⓟ 2026 Amy Castro

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it a bad idea to give a pet as a gift?

Not necessarily. Giving a pet as a gift can work wonderfully as long as the recipient is involved in choosing the animal and is fully prepared for the lifelong responsibility.

Why do animal shelters usually say no to surprise pet adoptions?

Rescues discourage surprise adoptions because they want to ensure the person actually wants the pet, is capable of caring for it, and has a voice in matching the animal's personality to their lifestyle.

How can you gift a pet for Christmas without making it a surprise responsibility?

You can wrap up pet supplies like a collar or leash, offer to pay adoption fees, or schedule a shelter visit after the holidays so the recipient can choose the right pet when things are calm.

Are pets given as gifts more likely to end up in shelters?

Research on this is mixed; studies do not support the myth that shelters are routinely flooded in January with unwanted Christmas puppies and kittens.

00:00 - Is Giving a Pet as a Gift Really a Bad Idea?

02:07 - What Research Really Says About Pets as Gifts

03:33 - Giving a Pet vs. Surprising Someone With One

06:26 - How to Surprise Someone Without Choosing for Them

07:11 - Why Rescues Say No to Surprise Pet Adoptions

09:39 - Mingy: When We Chose the Wrong Pet

14:29 - The BMW Surprise That Became a Burden

18:01 - Why You Shouldn't Surprise Someone Who's Grieving

18:55 - Giving a Puppy or Kitten to a Child

22:59 - The Christmas Puppy Surprise That Went Wrong

27:55 - How to Give a Pet as a Gift the Right Way

28:47 - Make the Gift Special, Not the Responsibility: A Surprise

THE PET PARENT HOTLINE

Pets as Gifts: What People Get Wrong & How to Do It Right

Host: Amy Castro, MA, CSP   •   Guest: None   •   Solo Episode

Episode Summary

Is giving a pet as a gift a bad idea? Host Amy Castro explains why gifting a pet and surprising someone with an unwanted responsibility are not the same thing. She shares rescue experiences, the story of a cat named Mingy, an unexpected BMW, and a Christmas puppy delivery to show why the recipient should help make the decision.

Links

petparenthotline.com

Recommended Resources

·        ASPCA Position Statement on Pets as Gifts: https://www.aspca.org/about-us/aspca-policy-and-position-statements/position-statement-pets-gifts

·        Should Dogs and Cats Be Given as Gifts? (2013): https://www.mdpi.com/2076-2615/3/4/995

·        Companion Animal Adoption and Relinquishment During the COVID-19 Pandemic (2022): https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/veterinary-science/articles/10.3389/fvets.2022.1017954/full

Veterinary and Behavior Disclaimer

The Pet Parent Hotline is for informational and educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional veterinary advice, diagnosis, treatment, or individualized behavior guidance. Always consult your veterinarian or a qualified animal behavior professional about your pet’s individual needs and any health or behavior concerns. Adoption policies and procedures vary by organization.

Transcript Note

This is a complete transcript of the episode. It has been lightly edited only for punctuation, capitalization, readability, and correction of obvious transcription errors. No spoken content has been intentionally omitted. Chapter timestamps are approximate estimates based on transcript position, not verified audio timecodes; please check them against the final recording before publishing.

Chapters (Estimated)

00:00 Is Giving a Pet as a Gift Really a Bad Idea?

02:07 What Research Really Says About Pets as Gifts

03:33 Giving a Pet vs. Surprising Someone With One

06:26 How to Surprise Someone Without Choosing for Them

07:11 Why Rescues Say No to Surprise Pet Adoptions

09:39 Mingy: When We Chose the Wrong Pet

14:29 The BMW Surprise That Became a Burden

18:01 Why You Shouldn't Surprise Someone Who's Grieving

18:55 Giving a Puppy or Kitten to a Child

22:59 The Christmas Puppy Surprise That Went Wrong

27:55 How to Give a Pet as a Gift the Right Way

28:47 Make the Gift Special, Not the Responsibility a Surprise


FULL TRANSCRIPT


When Giving Pets as Gifts Is a Good Idea  |  ~00:00

Amy Castro, Host

At my animal rescue, if someone came in wanting to adopt a dog or cat as a surprise gift for another adult, the answer was almost always no. We wanted the person who is actually gonna live with that pet to participate in the adoption. But here's something that might surprise you. After more than 16 years in animal rescue, I don't agree with the blanket advice that you should never give someone a pet as a gift. Giving a pet can be a wonderful gift. The problem is that people often confuse giving someone a pet with choosing the pet for them. And those are two very different things. And believe me, I've seen what happens when people get that distinction wrong.

And I've even made the mistake myself. You've reached the pet parent hotline, your lifeline for practical solutions for your toughest pet parenting challenges. And I'm your host, Amy Castro, and you know, every year, especially around the holidays, you'll see shelters and rescues warning people not to give pets as gifts. And I understand where they're coming from. They're worried about somebody bringing home a cute puppy or kitten without considering whether the recipient actually wants that pet or is prepared to care for it. And those are totally legitimate concerns.

But I think the blanket message that gets perpetuated on social media that pets should never be given as gifts really misses something important because there are plenty of ways to give someone a pet without making it an irresponsible decision. So today I want to talk about the difference between giving a pet and surprising somebody with one, and why finding the right match is so important, and how you can make giving a pet a really special occasion without making decisions that should belong to somebody else. And since we're headed into the holiday season, I'll tell you about a Christmas morning puppy delivery that we did through my rescue.

The parents had planned what they thought, I'm sure, would be a completely wonderful magical moment for their child. Unfortunately, it didn't really turn out that way.


What the Research Says About Gifted Pets  |  ~02:07

Amy Castro, Host

But before we get into all of that, let me address the argument that pets given as gifts are more likely to end up being surrendered. The research on that is actually quite mixed, and there's very little of it. A 2013 study involving people who'd received dogs and cats as gifts found that the vast majority said receiving the pet as a gift actually increased their attachment to the pet or didn't have an impact on their attachment with the pet. A later study in 2022 did raise concerns about higher rates of considering or actually giving up pets acquired as gifts.

Neither one of those things tells us that Christmas puppies or kittens are routinely being returned to shelters in January, and the research doesn't settle the distinction that I'm most interested in, which is whether the recipient was involved in choosing the pet or had it completely sprung on them unexpectedly. So I don't think the evidence gives us a good reason to make a blanket declaration that giving pets as gifts is always a bad idea. And even the ASPCA supports giving pets as gifts under appropriate circumstances. To me, the important question isn't whether somebody else paid for the pet or whether it arrived on a particular day or special occasion.

It's how that decision was made and whether that particular pet belongs in that particular home, like we always talk about.


A Gift Is Not the Same as a Surprise  |  ~03:33

Amy Castro, Host

So think about an engagement ring, something completely different for just a minute. Some people love the idea of being completely surprised with a ring that their partner picked out all by themselves, right? Other people have very specific ideas about what they want. You know, maybe they prefer a particular shape or a certain type of stone or a vintage ring. And then there's the practical stuff, like whether the ring actually even fits their finger. Now, if you know your partner really well, you might be able to choose the perfect ring without asking them a single question. But you might also discover that the ring you spent a fortune on isn't remotely what they would have chosen for themselves.

And I don't think an engagement ring becomes any less of a gift because the person receiving it helped choose it. If anything, you're probably increasing the odds that they'll love it and wear it for the rest of their lives. I think giving someone a pet works kind of the same way, except the stakes are a whole lot higher, because unlike a ring, that pet is a living being with a personality, preferences, and needs of their own. So you might know that your husband wants a dog. He's talked about getting one for years, and you've discussed the kind of dog that would fit your family.

But does that mean you should go to the shelter by yourself and pick out whatever dog you think he'll love? Maybe, but I think it sort of depends on your husband and who he is. If he's the kind of person who loves every dog he meets, trusts your judgment, and would happily let you choose, it might work out beautifully. But I've also met some husbands of friends of mine that are very, very particular about things, like even the paint color on the wall or where knick-knacks are on a shelf.

So if you have a spouse or partner who is particular about the dog that they like and they really want to be involved in choosing one themselves, then I'd think twice about going out and making that decision on your own, because here's what's going to happen. The first time that dog chews up the person's favorite shoes, you don't want to hear, well, I never would have picked this dog in the first place. And that's something we don't always consider when we're planning a surprise. If the recipient didn't have much say in the decision, what happens when things get difficult? You know, it's one thing to accept challenges that come with a decision you made yourself.

It's another thing to deal with the problems that came from a decision somebody else made for you. And I'm thinking in that latter situation, there's going to be a lot of blame game going on.


The Controlled Surprise  |  ~06:26

Amy Castro, Host

Now, suppose your husband has already met a dog he loves and is ready to adopt, but you suggest thinking about it for another day or two. And meanwhile, behind the scenes, you made arrangements with that rescue, and on his birthday, the very dog he chooses comes home. That's a completely different kind of surprise. He didn't know exactly when the dog would arrive, he didn't even necessarily know the dog would arrive, but he knew which dog he wanted, he'd already agreed to the responsibility, and you just found a special way to make it happen. And I like to call that a controlled surprise, right? You're preserving the excitement without completely surprising somebody with a life-changing commitment that they never agreed to.


Why Rescues Involve the Recipient  |  ~07:11

Amy Castro, Host

And this is where I think a lot of rescues and shelters are coming from when they discourage adopting pets as gifts. At my rescue, we'd hear things like, My mom really needs a dog, she's been so lonely since dad died, or my daughter just went through a divorce and I think having a puppy would cheer her up. Well, maybe. But maybe mom doesn't actually want to get up at six in the morning to walk a dog. Maybe she's enjoying the freedom of not having a pet to care for, or even if it's just temporarily. And maybe the recently divorced daughter is already overwhelmed with everything else going on in her life.

The problem when it comes to these types of gifts is people put their own spin on what another person wants and needs, and sometimes they genuinely believe they're doing something wonderful. They may even tell the rescue that the recipient's been begging for a pet when what that person actually said was they missed having a dog or might like to get one someday. So as a rescue, we had no reliable way to know whether those claims were accurate, especially when the recipient wasn't there to speak for themselves. And that's why I can't think of any instance when we adopted out a pet to somebody who planned to give it to another adult living in a different household as a surprise gift.

It wasn't because we believed pets couldn't be gifts, it was because we wanted to know that the person who would actually be responsible for the pet really wanted it and had a say in choosing it. And there are certainly degrees to this situation, and that's why I think these things need to be looked at on a case-by-case basis. A responsible 50-year-old adult human who is planning to help her 75-year-old mom adopt an older, easy-going cat and is prepared to take care of that cat if her mother can no longer manage the care, that's a different situation than an 18-year-old or a 20-year-old adopting a lab German Shepherd puppy mix for her recently divorced mom who works 80 hours a week.

But even in that first situation, I'd still want the 75-year-old mom to be part of the process because the person giving the gift might have the best intentions and still choose the wrong pet. And I know because I have done that myself.


Mingy: Choosing a Pet for Someone Else  |  ~09:39

Amy Castro, Host

Many years ago, my husband and I got a cat for my mother-in-law. His name ended up being Mingy, and the whole situation is a pretty good example of how people can convince themselves they're making a great decision when maybe they should be listening a little more carefully. My mother-in-law really wanted a dog, but given her age and her living circumstances at the time and her very poor eyesight, we were really concerned that she wasn't able to manage a dog physically or to care for it properly. As a matter of fact, we weren't just concerned, we knew it. So we thought maybe a cat would be a better choice. And it wasn't a completely random idea.

I had seen her interact with our cats. I thought that maybe if she had a cat of her own, she'd discover that she really enjoyed having one. And I specifically went seeking a cat that was as dog-like as I possibly could get, thinking that that might be more appealing, one that came when you called him, that would play, that kind of thing. And the other thing is that I was open to the idea of taking on another cat myself. And so I figured, well, no harm, no foul, right? In giving her the opportunity to try something new. If it didn't work out, we'd take the cat as our own.

And she did agree to it, although if I was being honest, I would describe her agreement as somewhat reluctant. And looking back, I think we place a lot more importance on the fact that she'd said yes than on the fact that she wasn't particularly enthusiastic about the idea. In fact, I had enough doubts that I told my husband while we were driving to go to the shelter to look at cats that as soon as his mother decided that she didn't want him, we were going to take him, and were you okay with that before we walked through the door? Because I definitely wasn't going to have that cat return to the shelter because our idea did not work out.

Well, one week later, almost to the day, Mingy the cat came home with us. It seemed like it was working out at first. She seemed to be happy with the cat, but then came the complaints. She said she was having difficulty scooping the litter box because she couldn't bend over and she couldn't see well. And you know what, that may have been a legitimate problem. But I also think she just didn't want a cat. She wanted a dog. And we'd convinced ourselves that we knew what would make her happy. Fortunately, like I said, we made arrangements to take Mingy if things didn't work out, so he had a home waiting for him.

But having a backup plan didn't necessarily make our decision a good one in the first place. And that part kind of really bothers me when I look back on it, that we were trying to give my mother-in-law companionship, and in the end, she wound up with nothing. We'd ruled out the dog because we knew she couldn't manage one, and then we tried to substitute a cat because we thought it would be better for her. But we really never solved the underlying problem, which was her loneliness or finding a pet that she genuinely wanted and could comfortably care for.

You know, and maybe we should have helped her spend more time with cats before making a commitment or explored whether there was a dog whose needs she could realistically meet, when maybe the answer would have been that pet ownership just wasn't a good fit for her life at that point. But that needed to be a decision that she was fully involved in rather than something we were trying to figure out for her. And that brings me back to the importance of choosing the right individual pet. I've seen people fall in love with a particular breed or the appearance of an animal without paying nearly enough attention to its personality.

A dog who's a wonderful companion for one person might be completely overwhelming for someone else. Or one cat might be outgoing and affectionate and comfortable in a busy household while others might be happiest in a quiet home with one or two people. There's also the chemistry that happens when people meet pets. You can't always predict which animal somebody's going to connect with, and you certainly can't guarantee that a pet will bond with the person you intended it for. So even when you're convinced you know somebody really, really well, involving them in the selection gives you a much better chance of finding a match that works for both of them.


The BMW Gift and Unwanted Obligations  |  ~14:29

Amy Castro, Host

And there's another reason to think carefully about choosing a pet for somebody else, and this one reminds me of one of the most shocking gifts I've ever received. Many years ago, my husband surprised me on Christmas Eve with a BMW. I had admired BMWs for years and had occasionally commented that I'd love to have one someday, and it was one of those things that sounded wonderful in theory, but I certainly didn't make any serious plans to buy one. But apparently he decided to make that dream come true. So with the family gathered around, he rolled up the garage door to reveal this beautiful BMW he'd purchased for me. And my first thought wasn't, oh my gosh, what an amazing gift.

My first thought was, how much did it cost and who's making the payments on this thing? Because there wasn't any such thing as his money, my money. It was our money. And I felt like he made an enormous financial decision without even discussing it with me. I'm telling you, he might as well have rolled up that garage door and introduced me to his other secret family that he had stashed somewhere else. That's how big of a shock it was. And the really frustrating thing was that he genuinely thought he'd done something wonderful.

He'd listened when I'd talked about wanting a BMW someday, and he'd found one he thought I'd love, and he planned this big exciting reveal and even involved my brother in the process. But what he hadn't considered was that admiring a car and wanting to take on that financial obligation of owning that car are two completely different things. And because I hadn't chosen to make the purchase, every time something went wrong with the car, I resented it. If it needed repairs or something about it annoyed me, I'd make a comment about how much I hated that car. Well, he took that very personally because in his mind, he'd given me this amazing gift and I wasn't appreciating it.

So now we had a car, I resented, a husband whose feelings were hurt, and a financial obligation that lasted for four years. And I think the same thing can happen when you surprise somebody with a pet that they haven't really agreed to get. Maybe your sister's always talked about wanting a dog, so you decide to get her a puppy for her birthday, and you pay the adoption fees, and you get the crate and supplies and show up at her house expecting her to be thrilled. But what if she's been putting off a dog because she can't really afford one right now, or because her work schedule is unpredictable and she doesn't have time to train a puppy?

You might have paid the initial cost, but you've also handed her years of expenses and responsibility and work that she wasn't prepared to take on. And if the puppy starts destroying her house, waking her up in the middle of the night, or develops behavior problems because she doesn't have time to address them, she's the one that has to deal with those consequences. And you know, maybe she's gonna rise to the occasion and end up loving that dog. It could happen. But maybe she'll resent the responsibility and perhaps even resent you for slapping it on her. So just like with my BMW, wanting something in theory isn't the same as deciding you're ready to live with everything that comes with it.


Gifting Pets After Loss or Life Changes  |  ~18:01

Amy Castro, Host

And this is especially important when you're thinking about giving a pet to someone who's going through a difficult time. You know, maybe someone has lost a spouse or gone through a divorce or even recently lost a pet. And of course you want to make them feel better, and maybe having another dog or cat would bring some happiness back into their life, but you don't get to decide when somebody else is ready for that. Some people want another pet almost immediately after losing one, while others might need months or years before they're ready. And sometimes people have decided that the pet that they lost is gonna be their last.

And I think you can offer help to find them another pet when they're ready, and you can even offer to pay for it. But you've got to let them decide whether that happens and when it happens.


Giving Pets to Children  |  ~18:55

Amy Castro, Host

Now, I do think this situation is a little different when you're talking about parents giving pets to their own children who live under their roof. For one thing, if you're bringing a pet into your household, you're ultimately responsible for that pet's care, regardless of whose birthday or Christmas present it's supposed to be. And I think most parents understand that. In my experience in running a rescue, I did not encounter a lot of parents who genuinely thought that their eight-year-old was going to handle every aspect of caring for the new dog. What I did see were families who hadn't really considered how the pet was going to fit into their already busy lives. Everybody's excited about getting a puppy.

I think every single kid at some point in their life wants a puppy, a kitten, or whatever, fill in the blank for their birthday or for Christmas or something else. But between school, work, sports, after school activities, and everything else going on in a busy family's life, very often there's nobody that has enough time to do the training consistently or provide the exercise or attention that, let's say, a puppy needs. And before long, that adorable little puppy has grown into a 75-pound bundle of energy with terrible manners.

Now the family's overwhelmed, and the dog may end up spending most of its time in a crate or in the backyard, or being surrendered to a rescue because the family can't manage it anymore. And I'm not suggesting that every busy family shouldn't have a dog, but parents need to think realistically about the kind of pet they're getting and who's gonna meet that pet's needs. A cat might be a lot easier for some families to manage because you're not dealing with walks and outdoor potty training, but cats still need attention and enrichment and medical care, and choosing the wrong cat for your household can create its own problems.

You also have to really know your kids, as opposed to projecting how you want your kids to be onto them. Most kids would probably be pretty excited getting a puppy or a kitten, but that doesn't mean every child wants every kind of pet. Let's say your little girl, for example, has been obsessed with Marie from the Aristocats for the last two years, and all she talks about is wanting a beautiful white kitten just like Marie. Well, you might have a major problem on your hands if you surprise her with a black and white kitten instead.

On the other hand, if you've taken your children to shelters before and they absolutely love every kitten they meet, you probably have a lot of flexibility in choosing one. And beyond preferences, you need to pay attention to how your children actually behave around animals. Are they comfortable with dogs? Are they frightened by barking or jumping up? Can they handle a puppy's energy or would an older, calmer dog be a better fit? Can they respect a cat's boundaries and leave it alone when it wants some space? Or a dog.

Those are the kind of things we looked at when families brought their children to our rescue, and it's why I encourage parents to involve their kids in the process, especially when adopting dogs. But even if the child chooses the pet, there's no guarantee that pet is going to bond most closely with them. The dog might decide dad's his favorite person or the kitten might spend every night sleeping on mom's pillow, and that, unfortunately, or maybe fortunately, is just part of life with pets. You can influence the relationship, but you can't completely control it.

So I have no problem with parents surprising their children with pets, provided they've considered the child's personality and preferences, chosen an appropriate pet for their entire household, and are genuinely prepared to take on the responsibility for its care. Because when you're giving a pet to a child, you're making a commitment on the behalf of yourself and the whole family.


Christmas Puppies and the Perfect Surprise  |  ~22:59

Amy Castro, Host

And that brings us to Christmas, which is probably when the whole debate over giving pets as gifts gets the most attention. I mentioned earlier that every year you'll see warnings from rescues and shelters all over social media about the unwanted Christmas puppies and kittens that supposedly end up being returned after the holidays. And I think that there probably are individual circumstances at individual shelters or rescues, or maybe even just certain years where those numbers have been high. But here's something interesting from my own experience. In all the years I've operated a rescue, first of all, the number of people specifically looking for Christmas morning puppies or kittens was surprisingly small compared to the number of people adopting pets generally.

We even offer Christmas morning delivery as an option for families who'd been approved to adopt, and I think we probably did maybe certainly fewer than five. So when people say Christmas pets get returned a lot after the holidays, I'd be very curious as to where those numbers come from. Now there is one delivery that I will never forget. We had a parent who told us that their child wanted a puppy, and they understood that it would ultimately be a family pet. They went through the adoption process and we arranged to bring the puppy to their house on Christmas morning. Now, you can imagine what everybody hoped would happen.

We'd show up at the door with this adorable puppy, the kid would be thrilled, and the family would have this wonderful Christmas memory, or perhaps a great video to put on Instagram. Except that's not at all what happened. When we arrived with the puppy, the little boy at the door did not seem particularly excited at all. As a matter of fact, his mom must have said fifty times, Aren't you excited? Aren't you excited? And I was thinking, the kid's not excited. And I remember thinking this wasn't quite the reaction you'd expect from a child who really had been wanting a puppy. And guess what? Within a week, the family returned the dog.

And I honestly don't remember the specific reason they gave for returning the puppy, but I do remember that that whole experience was a reminder that even when parents think they're creating something wonderful for their child, things don't always turn out the way they imagined. And I think people sometimes get so invested in the idea of creating that hallmark, Instagram, whatever you want to call it moment that they don't spend enough time considering what happens after.

We've all seen those adorable Christmas videos where kids open a box and discover a puppy inside and everyone's in tears, or somebody brings a kitten into the room wearing a big red bow, and everybody screams and cries happy tears, and somebody gets a video that they'll treasure forever. But what happens when the recording stops? What happens when that puppy starts chewing on the Christmas tree lights and pees on the carpet, scratches grandma, or starts crying because it's overwhelmed and doesn't know where it is. What happens when the family has 20 people coming over for dinner and everybody wants to pick the kitten up and pass it around and take pictures?

All of that excitement may make for a wonderful Christmas memory for the family for about 60 seconds, but it could be a pretty terrible introduction to a new home for a pet that's just been taken away from everything that they know. And to be fair, Christmas morning isn't necessarily the worst possible time to bring home a pet. If your household is quiet on Christmas Day and you've already planned for the pet's arrival and everyone understands how to give the pet time and space to adjust, I don't see anything inherently wrong with it. But I do think you have to be realistic about what Christmas looks like in your particular home.

At our rescue, when people wanted to bring home a pet for the holidays, we made sure that they had a plan for giving the pet some space and quiet. They needed to have something set up in advance where the pet could get comfortable without being overwhelmed by visitors or excited kids. And that's going to be a lot easier in some households than others. If your kids are old enough to understand that a puppy needs to rest and can't be picked up and carried around all day, great.

But if you've got five and six-year-olds who are going to chase the kitten everywhere it goes, you might want to think about whether Christmas morning is the best time to bring a kitten home. Then if you're leaving the following morning to visit relatives out of town, I'd seriously question the wisdom of bringing home a new pet the day before.


Better Ways to Gift a Pet  |  ~27:55

Amy Castro, Host

The good news is you don't have to abandon the idea of a special gift just because Christmas morning isn't the right time for the actual pet to arrive. You can wrap up a collar, a leash, a carrier, or some supplies, and let the person know that the pet they've already chosen will be coming home in a few days when things are calmer. Or you could surprise them with a trip to a rescue or a shelter the day after Christmas if they're open, where they get to meet available pets and participate in choosing the one that's right for them.

Maybe the gift is simply that you're going to pay an adoption fee for somebody or that you've offered to help with supplies or preparations. There are so many ways to make giving a pet memorable without making the pet's arrival a chaotic experience.


Final Takeaway: Involve the Recipient  |  ~28:47

Amy Castro, Host

So the bottom line is I wish that we would stop telling people that they should never give pets as gifts and start talking more about what makes a pet a good gift in the first place. Because I don't believe the problem is the gift itself. It's when someone gets so excited about the idea of doing something wonderful for another person that they forget to involve that person in decisions that matter. And I can certainly understand how that happens. I've been on both sides of it, with the BMW and with giving my mother-in-law the cat. Neither of those gifts worked out the way the giver intended, and I think there's a lesson in that.

A gift doesn't become more meaningful simply because it's a surprise. Sometimes the most thoughtful thing you can do is let somebody tell you exactly what they want and then find a special way to give it to them. So if you're thinking about giving someone a pet for Christmas or their birthday or any other occasion, don't feel that involving them in the decision somehow ruins the gift. Let them help choose the pet. Let them decide when they're ready or whether they're ready for the commitment. And if you want to create a magical moment, get creative and have some fun in how you make that happen.

Because the real gift isn't the look on somebody's face when you show up with a puppy wearing a bow. It's the opportunity for that person and the pet to build a wonderful relationship that lasts a lifetime. And that's something worth getting right. If you know someone who's thinking about giving a pet as a gift this holiday season, please share this episode with them. Maybe it'll help them look at the decision a little differently and find a way to make the gift special for everyone involved, including the pet. Thanks for listening to the Pet Parent Hotline. If you enjoyed the show, text a friend right now and tell them I've got a show that you need to hear.

And remember, your pet's best life starts with you living yours. So take good care of yourself this week and your pets.