If Your Dog Bites Someone: What Every Owner Must Know
Key Takeaways
- Dog owners should proactively review their homeowners or renter's insurance policies to understand specific breed exclusions and verify their level of liability coverage before an incident occurs.
- Attempting to privately pay medical bills after a dog bite, especially with friends or family, can backfire and accidentally create the perception of guilt or cause future disputes if unexpected medical costs arise.
- Liability for a dog goes beyond actual bites; owners can be held legally responsible for injuries caused when a pet scratches, knocks someone down, or causes someone to fall while trying to get away.
- Maryland personal injury attorney Jason Plotkin emphasizes that contacting your insurance company promptly after a dog bite helps preserve relationships and keeps the claims process from becoming unnecessarily combative.
- Living in a homeowners association (HOA) or renting an apartment means you must strictly follow local and community pet guidelines regarding breed restrictions and reporting requirements to avoid severe financial and legal penalties.
Think your dog would never bite someone? Think again. Even the sweetest, friendliest dog can bite when frightened, startled, hurt, or pushed too far. And one bite could have serious consequences for you, the person who was bitten, and your dog's future.
This is an episode every dog owner must hear, whether their dog has bitten someone or not.
Maybe your dog has never shown the slightest sign of aggression, and you can't imagine them ever hurting anyone. Maybe they've growled at visitors, snapped when startled, or shown fear around strangers. Or maybe your dog has already bitten someone, and you're worried about the consequences if it happens again.
Whatever your situation, do you know your legal and financial responsibilities if your dog bites someone? Will your homeowners or renters insurance cover the injuries? What if the person who gets bitten is a friend or family member who insists they'd never sue you? Could a Beware of Dog sign help or hurt you? And what could happen to your dog after a bite?
In this episode of The Pet Parent Hotline, I'm joined by Maryland personal injury attorney Jason Plotkin to discuss the legal, financial, and personal consequences of dog bites, and what every dog owner should know BEFORE an incident happens.
You'll learn:
- What to do immediately after a dog bite, including medical care, vaccination records, and notifying your insurance company.
- Why your homeowners or renters insurance might not cover a bite, including breed exclusions and coverage gaps you might not know exist.
- Why paying someone's medical bills yourself can backfire, even when the person injured is a close friend or family member.
- How you could be held responsible even if your dog never actually bites someone, such as when a dog scratches, knocks someone down, or causes an injury while someone is trying to get away.
- How your dog's bite history, warning signs, and the precautions you've taken can affect your liability, including the surprising legal considerations surrounding Beware of Dog signs.
- Why local ordinances, apartment rules, and HOA restrictions matter, and how failing to understand or follow them could create additional problems.
Jason also shares his personal story of being bitten by a family member's dog as a child and how that experience inspired his book, The Pickle, the Patch, and the Puppy, which helps children rebuild their confidence around dogs after a frightening experience.
The worst time to learn about dog bite liability is after someone gets hurt. Whether your dog has bitten before or has never given you a reason to worry, you need this information now, while you still have the opportunity to prepare and prevent problems.
Resources Mentioned
- Jason Plotkin and the Pinder Plotkin Legal Team: https://pinderplotkin.com
- The Pickle, the Patch, and the Puppy: https://pickleandthepuppy.com
This episode provides general educational information, not legal advice. Dog bite laws, reporting requirements, insurance coverage, and rental or HOA restrictions vary by location. Review your policies and local requirements, and consult a qualified attorney about your specific circumstances.
Know someone with a dog? Share this episode with them now, not after something happens.
Stuck on a pet problem? Send it here.
Practical pet advice for busy pet parents.
Love the show? Follow The Pet Parent Hotline so you don’t miss an episode, and share this one with a pet parent who needs it.
Listen & Follow: 🌍Official Site |📱Facebook |📺YouTube | 🍏 Apple |🎵Spotify
The Pet Parent Hotline covers real-world dog and cat behavior, training, pet health and nutrition, veterinary decisions, pet-care costs, aging pets, and everyday life with animals.
No fluff. No guilt. Just useful advice to help you make smarter decisions and enjoy life with your pets.
Help us reach more pet parents like you: A 5-star rating or review on Apple Podcasts helps new listeners feel confident trying us out.
Contact: Amy@petparenthotline.com
©Ⓟ 2026 Amy Castro
Frequently Asked Questions
Does homeowners insurance cover dog bites?
Homeowners and renter's insurance policies often cover dog bites, but you must check your specific policy for breed exclusions and coverage limits. Failing to disclose an excluded breed can result in the insurance company denying coverage, leaving you personally liable.
What should I do immediately after my dog bites someone?
First, take care of the injured person by helping with wound care and assessing if they need urgent medical attention. Next, have your rabies documentation ready, and promptly notify your insurance company to report the incident and ensure a smooth claims process.
Can I be held liable if my dog doesn't actually bite someone?
Yes, dog owners can be held legally responsible if their pet causes an injury through scratching, knocking someone down, or frightening someone so badly that they fall and get hurt while trying to escape.
Why is paying a dog bite medical bill privately a bad idea?
Paying medical bills out of pocket can be viewed as an admission of liability in some cases. Furthermore, if medical costs escalate later due to infections or complications, informal private agreements frequently break down and lead to damaged relationships or legal disputes.
00:00 - What Every Dog Parent Should Know About Bites
02:01 - Check Your Insurance Before a Bite Happens
05:13 - Breed Identification, Exclusions, and Disclosure
08:21 - When a Dog Causes Injury Without Biting
10:31 - What to Do Immediately After a Dog Bite
12:46 - When Friends and Family Say They Won’t Sue
14:54 - Why Paying Medical Bills Privately Can Backfire
16:40 - Beware of Dog Signs and Legal Liability
19:42 - Precautions After a Dog Has Bitten Someone
21:24 - Long-Term Insurance Consequences
22:54 - HOA Rules and Restrictions
24:29 - Two Key Steps to Protect Yourself
25:36 - Jason’s Childhood Bite Story and His Book
29:55 - Final Takeaways and Resources
If Your Dog Bites Someone: What Every Owner Must Know
THE PET PARENT HOTLINE • AMY CASTRO WITH JASON PLOTKIN
Disclaimer: This episode is provided for general educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws regarding dog bites, liability, and the responsibilities of dog owners vary by state and locality. The information shared reflects the perspectives and experiences of our guest and should not be considered a substitute for advice from a qualified attorney. If your dog has bitten someone or you've been injured by a dog, consult an attorney licensed in your jurisdiction about your specific situation.
Chapter Markers
00:00 What Every Dog Parent Should Know About Bites
02:01 Check Your Insurance Before a Bite Happens
05:13 Breed Identification, Exclusions, and Disclosure
08:21 When a Dog Causes Injury Without Biting
10:31 What to Do Immediately After a Dog Bite
12:46 When Friends and Family Say They Won’t Sue
14:54 Why Paying Medical Bills Privately Can Backfire
16:40 Beware of Dog Signs and Legal Liability
19:42 Precautions After a Dog Has Bitten Someone
21:24 Long-Term Insurance Consequences
22:54 HOA Rules and Restrictions
24:29 Two Key Steps to Protect Yourself
25:36 Jason’s Childhood Bite Story and His Book
29:55 Final Takeaways and Resources
Transcript
Lightly cleaned for readability. Timestamps are taken from the supplied transcript.
00:00 | What Every Dog Parent Should Know About Bites
Amy Castro 00:00
Your dog bites someone. Now what? Do you call the insurance company, offer to pay the medical bills yourself, or try to work things out privately? And could one bite put your dog's future at risk? Today we're talking about what happens after a dog bite, what every dog parent should know before it happens, and the mistakes you don't want to make. You've reached the pet parent hotline. I'm Amy Castro. You know, when you hear about dog bites, it's usually from the perspective of the person who was hurt.
But today we're looking at what happens from the dog parent side. My guest is Jason Plotkin, a Maryland personal injury attorney who handles dog bite cases, amongst other things. And we're going to talk about what you should do immediately after a bite, what your homeowner's or renter's insurance may or may not cover, and why trying to work things out privately with a friend or family member even could end up making matters worse.
But first, there's something else I want to address because I know it's something you'd really worry about if your dog bit someone beyond the person's injuries, and that is what happens to your dog. Depending on where you live and the circumstances, animal control may investigate, and your dog may have to undergo a quarantine or observation period for rabies, either at animal control, a veterinarian, and sometimes at your own home.
More serious incidents can lead to restrictions on your dog or in extreme cases, euthanasia. But those aren't automatic consequences with every bite. And one important reminder before we get started, Jason is going to share general information in this episode, not legal advice for your particular situation, because laws and reporting requirements vary. Insurance policies have different coverages and exclusions. And apartment complexes and homeowners associations may have their own rules.
So it's super important to know your coverage and the requirements where you live before something happens. All right, let's get into it. So, Jason, welcome to the show.
Jason Plotkin 02:00
Amy, thanks for having me.
02:01 | Check Your Insurance Before a Bite Happens
Amy Castro 02:01
Yeah, I appreciate that you reached out because I think there's a lot of misinformation or maybe just a lack of information on the part of pet owners when it comes to pet bites, but specifically dog bites. So I want to kind of start before a bite. So what is it that people should know, whether it's about their homeowners' insurance or renter's insurance or even like I run into a lot, apartment policies when they're when they're renting? What should they know about that going into it?
Jason Plotkin 02:30
Sure. Well, the biggest thing is you want to pull out your policy if you have an animal at home, dogs or otherwise, and read it to see what is covered and what's not covered. Because dog lovers have multiple dogs throughout their lives. And a lot of times they just keep hitting their renewal on the homeowner's insurance, or they take their policy and just shop it to another company and just take the same coverage. But you might have added a dog that could be excluded.
The insurance company might have changed the terminology of the way they describe a breed or how they limit coverage. So you want to be very, very cognizant of what that says because you want to know what coverage you have. That's the key to protect you in case something happens. Then you kind of go into where do you live? Because you also have to know what local ordinances. I'm here in Maryland. we used to have a couple counties that had pit bull exclusions that since been overturned and changed.
But if you had that exclusion and you lived in that county and you got insurance, they probably would void your insurance if you had a dog what essentially they would consider illegal at that time. So you want to understand where you live, what the restrictions are, and that could be a county level, township, city, statewide, that's very important. Then it goes to renters' insurance. You mentioned that again, apartment complexes. Yeah, it's very important to have renters coverage in general.
So if you rent anywhere a house, townhouse, an apartment, get coverage because the landlord has policies that protect them, protects the house. Doesn't protect your personal possessions. It also doesn't protect you if an animal you have bites somebody or there's an incident at your house, someone trips and falls, things like that. So you want to make sure you have personal coverage. You also got to be very careful of these policies that are sold by the apartment complexes.
A lot of large complexes, they have this kind of like self-insure, or they have a deal with an insurance company. And anytime they're kind of pitching you something, you gotta think, why are they doing this? And a lot of times those rental coverages only protect your property or some degree of the apartment or the lodging where you are, and not your liability, and a lot of times not even your personal possessions.
I get a lot of phone calls from people that say they have this insurance and we dig into it, and there is a hundred pages of exclusions. It's not this, it's not this. It covers a small, narrow sliver, and usually is to protect an insurance company covering the apartment complex. Right to help them. So knowing your coverage is the most important thing you could do.
You might also, if it's a mixed breed and you think it's got something that could be excluded, if you can afford it, get a DNA test, talk to your vet, find out exactly what it is because it's one of those things. Knowledge is power, knowledge can be prevention as well.
05:13 | Breed Identification, Exclusions, and Disclosure
Amy Castro 05:13
Yeah. I'm glad you brought that up because I have recommended that to many people over the years, because just like we were talking about before with your dog who, you know, supposedly a lab, but turns out to be something completely different. So many times we identify a pet's breed, you know, especially if it's something we got from a rescue or a shelter or we know it's a mixed breed, we look at it, we say, what does it look like?
Well, what it looks like, and there's been a ton of research on this subject, even having experts look at certain animals and say, that's absolutely a pit bull, or that's absolutely this. And it turns out to have zero in it.
I think the catch 22 with that, and it kind of ties to the next question that I wanted to ask too, was sometimes people don't want to know because if I don't know, then I don't have to reveal that I have a pit bull that might be excluded from this apartment or might make my insurance higher or non-existent, or they'll just flat out like they know what it is, and they decide either not to be honest or not to tell. What's the ramifications of doing that?
Jason Plotkin 06:17
Sure. Well, and I should preface this whole conversation as this is not legal advice, this is educational. You know, you gotta go to a lawyer in your local jurisdiction. All that being said, it depends. You hit on a couple things there. One is does everybody need to get their dogs DNA tested? No. Typically in your vet records, there's gonna be a breed listed, and I think it's reasonable to rely upon that.
Amy Castro 06:39
Okay. Right?
Jason Plotkin 06:39
That's a trained professional and they have a breed in there. I think that's that's reasonable. Right? So the most people I think would probably want to get the DNA test is the reverse if the vet identifies as a breed that could be excluded and they want to double check or make sure. Some states have like a mixed percentage.
You know, so for a mixed breed, they'll have a certain percentage or wherever's leaning could be the way where it goes, which is why you want to get a local opinion to see exactly what happens there. That's important. However, the other aspect of it is you're saying, well, you know. So that vet record shows that it's excluded breed, or you're you got a DNA test and it shows it's excluded breed. Well, it's excluded breed.
You buy insurance, you're wasting your money to a degree, especially if you get any kind of pet or animal rider, and you don't disclose the breed and the breed's excluded, because it's gonna say the exclusions in there. They'll have the standard language, and then what's gonna happen? An incident occurs, animal control, the police, another vet, somebody gets involved and identifies the breed. And your insurance company excludes it, which means you're personally responsible.
And we want to avoid all of these things, but the average dog bite is much more expensive than the average car accident. So people don't really correlate that together. And these can be very serious. Even small little accidents happen, right? Yeah. We're not talking about like vicious dogs, we're talking about possibly a confused dog, something happens and it just nips because it got scared. Good dogs make a bad decision, right?
Amy Castro 08:10
Yeah.
Jason Plotkin 08:11
Is one way to say it. versus the other, which is a whole other story about you know, people abusing dogs and causing other issues. nothing good comes from hiding it.
08:21 | When a Dog Causes Injury Without Biting
Amy Castro 08:21
Okay. Yeah, that's good to know because I think people think they're it's like, yeah, you get away with it until you don't. It's like anything else, right? And then when you don't, you're in way deeper than if you'd have just made a good decision in the first place.
You know, one of the other things, like you said, and I think it's important to note that the laws and the ordinances and things like that are different in various places, but where my rescue is, just as an example, if an animal draws blood, it is considered a bite, which means even if it is like I and this actually happened recently to a friend of mine where a dog that was staying at her house got loose and jumped on somebody and they're you know, 99% sure the dog only scratched with her claws.
And even the person who got scratched felt like it was a scratch and the dog, you know, did not bite them. But because it drew blood, it was treated as a dog bite case and it had to quarantine the dog and go through that whole scenario. So that's something to know as well. Like what are the rules in your community for that purpose as well.
Jason Plotkin 09:26
Exactly. And they're generally fairly easy to find out. And a lot of these we call them dog bites, but they're more like dog incidents or animal incidents where you could be knocked down, you could be scratched, you could be scared and you run away from a dog. Right? A dog gets loose, never makes contact with you, but you fall and break your hip running across the yard. Right? That happens a lot.
Amy Castro 09:46
Okay. Yeah. So it's so it goes beyond the biting and just liability for the actions or activities of your pet in those instances. So it's good to know.
Jason Plotkin 09:54
And a lot of them it's not even the pet really, it's it's the actions of the owner, or usually it's a and this is key for a lot of people, it's usually a young child, a friend visiting, or somebody that's house sitting because they don't know the dog's propensity, right? You know, hey, I always have to like close the dog gate when I go to open the front door because they're gonna run out. Right.
There's there's little things that people miss and they seem to cause a lot of that stuff, especially in this DoorDash world. A hungry, playful dog smells food at the front door, and your teenager's friend opens the door, dog runs out, or the dog does something that scares the driver.
10:31 | What to Do Immediately After a Dog Bite
Amy Castro 10:31
Yeah. So definitely something to be aware of. So let's talk specifically about a bite. So let's just say I'm in a situation where I'm in my own home, a friend or family member comes over, and my dog does actually bite them. What do I do?
Jason Plotkin 10:46
Exactly. And that's one of the most common things that happen. You want to first off take care of the family member or friend. You do the wound care, wash the wound, triage it, see if they need to go to an urgent care or hospital to get checked out. Because there's a lot of risk for infection. Dogs are very playful outside with some nasty stuff sometimes. So there can be bacteria in there. So you've got to be very careful about wound care.
You want to have your rabies documentation easily accessible so that you can give it to the your friend or family member, or at least confirm it to them so they can convey it to any medical provider. You want to call your insurance company and report it. Let them know what happened. That's very important because that makes it much smoother later because your friend or family member at some point may make a claim against your homeowner's insurance because it is a claim.
I mean, that's what you bought the insurance for. So it's very important to keep that perspective. It's not a lawsuit against you, it's not coming after you personally. You bought insurance, something happened, and it's an insurance claim. We have had a lot of cases. In fact, one case involved a woman and her best friend. an incident happened when she was trying to help her friend feed the dog.
She hired us to come in and take over the communication because her and her friend, I think, came into that agreement that she should hire a lawyer because they wanted us to be able to talk to her friend's insurance company, and that way they could stay best friends and just deal with it and didn't have to deal with the frustration that does come with an insurance company. So by having an independent party in that conversation, it helped preserve their relationship and it got resolved.
And a lawsuit only comes when the insurance process breaks down. Contacting your insurance company and cooperating with them sets that stage. Otherwise, if the insurance company hears about it from a lawyer or somebody else first, first they're gonna be upset with you. Second, it sets it at a different posture, more combative, and it could impact your rate, especially depending on how long it takes, because insurance companies keep track of that. They index everything.
And if you take six months or a year and they get notified by a claim by somebody else, not you, they're gonna be like, okay, the this person's risky, right? They're not taking the right steps.
12:46 | When Friends and Family Say They Won’t Sue
Amy Castro 12:46
Yeah. And I think you said something important there about well, you said a lot of things that were important, but one that really stuck in my head that I wanted to dive into a little bit more was the idea that the you know, the action is not against you as a human being, because one of the things that I always tell people, like even with volunteers, you know, I've had volunteers who they haven't completed our insurance company's required training yet.
And they but they want that puppy or they want that kitten in their house. And it's like, you know, I can't let you have the puppy or the kitten because if you get scratched or whatever, you know, even with cats, you know, scratch turns into an infection. Now you're in the emergency room, and you know, it it becomes an issue. Oh, I would never sue you, I would never report it. Well, it's not even a matter of whether you think you would. You may, in your heart of hearts, not believe you would ever do that.
But when you get to the emergency room, the hospital can report it if it's a if it's an animal bite, especially a dog bite. the other thing that can happen, and I've seen this happen too, where I didn't in my heart of hearts, let's say, think that I would ever want to hold my friend responsible, but now my insurance company's not covering it, and I've got a $10,000 emergency room bill or 15 or 20 or whatever it is, and I can't pay it. So here we go.
And so it's not about, like you said, the relationship between that other person. It becomes something outside of both human beings at that point. And I think you know, both parties need to look out for their own best interest in those cases, and they will. You know, that's what's gonna happen.
Jason Plotkin 14:19
Well, exactly. You brought up a good point. So a lot of times these things don't look serious in the beginning, right? It could be they look superficial, but it turns out there could be an infection, could be some nerve damage, there could be a little bit of PTSD trauma that comes involved in it, and these things kind of fester over time.
Amy Castro 14:36
Yeah.
Jason Plotkin 14:37
And and it becomes a bigger deal later. And like you said, the bills might pile up. A lot of people have high deductible plans nowadays, so it can be very expensive, especially to get a wound taken care of if you need dermatologists or a plastic surgeon to help. they can definitely add up fast.
14:54 | Why Paying Medical Bills Privately Can Backfire
Amy Castro 14:54
Yeah. What about sometimes people's inclination, and this happens with car accidents as well? Like, hey, let's not report it. I'll, you know, I'll cover the bill, especially if it's a family member. You know, my dog bites my cousin, he goes to the ER, it's you know, it's $2,000, and I say, hey, I'll pay for that, let's not report it. What's the downside of doing that for the insurance finding out later?
Jason Plotkin 15:15
Yeah, there's a couple of things. One thing I'll say is it can look as an admission of guilt. Different states have different laws. Maryland is where I'm at strict liability, but it's really a presumption against the dog owner. A lot of times that's like a one-bite rule people hear about, like they hear strict liability and one bite rule. But a lot of times the idea is dogs might have to have a series or history of causing something.
Amy Castro 15:37
Right.
Jason Plotkin 15:38
So there comes the idea of are you paying money because you feel responsible and you want to help out your friend or family, which is is very reasonable, right? Somebody's got to co-pay, especially a younger family member that might not have that much money to pay for the ER bill. Yeah, that's fine too, but you got to be mindful of that. What I see more often is the other side where the person says, Don't worry about it. You say, Hey, here's $500, we cover the medical bills. And they're like, Don't worry about it.
And then three months, six months later, those medical bills start to come in and it's in the thousands, and they're like, that person only wanted to offer me $500. And then it reframes it psychologically in them that you were trying to take advantage of them. That's a lot of the phone calls we get, and we get that little angeriness in their voice. Like, they didn't understand what I'm going through. And the fact of the matter is, well, you weren't really going through that when they offered that money, right?
They offered a certain amount based upon what they thought your bills were going to be. That tends to make things grow and become bigger, which is why I always say that self-help can really cause a bigger issue later. It's better to just go right to your insurance company.
16:40 | Beware of Dog Signs and Legal Liability
Amy Castro 16:40
Yeah. So you had mentioned that, you know, the animal's history. If it wasn't the first time, how does that change things? Or when I just moved here to my new house, Amazon people were coming into my yard and putting packages in the backyard fenced area. So I wanted to put up a sign like beware of dog. And then I started Googling it and it's like, well, you know, are you implying that your dogs are dangerous? And it's like, well, my dogs have never bitten anybody, but I don't know what would provoke them to do it.
If you're kicking your feet at them, I've got a chihuahua that might take a piece out of you. I don't know. Actually, she can't, she doesn't have any teeth, but you know, it's like I just started second guessing the whole thing. So I actually bought a sign that says something like, please be careful not to open the gate, dogs are in the yard, like just some kind of vague thing that people know I have a dog, but not like a beware of dog, dog biting. and I know that's two different issues.
So there's the, you know, the one side where a person knows that their dog has bitten or at least has the propensity to bite, and then the sign issue. I don't know if you want to tackle either one of those, if that makes sense.
Jason Plotkin 17:48
It definitely does. And a lot of it depends on where you live. Maryland, while they have a very good strict liability and they have what's also called contributory negligence, which is only one of a few states in the country where if somebody's even the slightest bit contributing, so like that 1%, you can't recover. Other states have like a comparative which has a formula, can be less than 49%, less than 50%, different percentage breakdowns.
So a sign can help get to a contrib or show that someone was comparatively negligent because they once or more they shouldn't have.
Amy Castro 18:19
Just so to clarify, what you're saying is the person who was bitten contributed to the bite incident in some form or fashion. And that's a that's a good point. And I noticed on your website there was a a page that I saw that and it was based on Maryland law that was literally broken out by the age of the person. And I thought that is fascinating. I never would have thought of that. You know, like a two-year-old gets bitten versus a 17-year-old gets bitten.
Jason Plotkin 18:43
Exactly, because the medical science behind it and how much a child can comprehend the risk and things along those lines to contribute to their actions. And each state can be different. Because a lot of times that's not by statute, it's by case law. So the courts decide over time. But where it could help or hurt you, it would depend on the circumstances. Because all these are very fact-specific.
So a beware of dog sign definitely helps that comparative or contributory negligence defense, because you were saying, hey, this is a dog you gotta be very careful of, right? Beware of this dog. You stepped in the yard with a sign that said, Hey, this dog's dangerous. So that is a very good defense. The idea where you're talking about on the other side is for the dog standpoint, are you already making a determination the dog is dangerous? So it's kind of like a cost-benefit analysis.
And I would say if the certain dogs are going to be protective and beware of dogs, it's probably pretty good. You're saying stay out. I think that's a very reasonable step to take. A lot of it depends on the circumstances.
19:42 | Precautions After a Dog Has Bitten Someone
Amy Castro 19:42
Yeah. And I would assume that if an owner does have an animal that they've known, like we had a dog named Bonnie, actually bit my husband. And so my philosophy was if a dog's bitten once, it will bite again. Apparently that's not really true, but that's the way I operated. And so we always put her up when people came over, those kinds of things, just to not even have her in contact with other people, basically. And she lived out her life just fine.
But do owners have a responsibility or does it help, I guess, from a liability standpoint? If you've proven I've I went to the trainer, I did this, I did this to prevent people from having contact with my dog because I know she's not good with other with people, strangers.
Jason Plotkin 20:22
Well, there's a couple ways to answer it. So it can help, definitely, but also can hurt because it creates more knowledge of everything. But if it's your responsibility, it's your responsibility. If there would go to, say, a lawsuit and you'd be in front of a judge or a jury, you're gonna look much more reasonable as a dog owner if you took all those steps. You don't want to get people upset at you, right? or look unreasonable, look greedy, look like you just don't really care.
So I wouldn't necessarily be as afraid of taking those steps. There's also the kind of the moral obligation to a degree. If something happened and it happens again, how are you gonna feel about it? Are you gonna feel that you've taken some steps to try to prevent it? Especially if it involves a child.
Amy Castro 21:02
Yeah.
Jason Plotkin 21:03
Right? Because a lot of times there's certain dogs that just aren't good with children. I mean, children don't know limits. They they tug on ears, they tug on tails, they try to pull food out of the mouth. But I mean, there's a lot of things that kind of happen when children visit with a relative that has a dog.
Amy Castro 21:18
Yeah.
Jason Plotkin 21:19
So so I tend to lean on that most and say, if it happens again, what are you gonna wish you had done?
21:24 | Long-Term Insurance Consequences
Amy Castro 21:24
Hmm. Yeah, that's a good point. And I think that's with a lot of things. If there are preventative steps you can take, then you can better live with whatever the outcome is later on down the road. Yeah. What have you seen with some of these cases? What are some of the long-term impacts? Because I'm thinking about things like getting your insurance canceled or having somebody legally come in and say you need to euthanize your pet. I mean, I've seen all kinds of stories, but what do you see?
Jason Plotkin 21:50
Well, I mean, rip the band-aid off, your insurance rates could go up, or probably will go up. Fact of the matter is, if nothing happens, they're probably going to go up already anyway, right? I mean, that's It just kind of happens. So you don't always know what they're going to do or how they're going to do it.
Amy Castro 22:04
Yeah.
Jason Plotkin 22:04
But if you still have the dog and the dog has an incident, it's going to increase the risk to you and to the insurance company. Anytime they spend any money on you, it's going to happen. Yeah. So the key, which a lot of people don't realize, or I think they realize, but just don't actually do, is you can shop insurance.
A lot of times you stay with the same insurance company forever and you feel like you're being loyal, they're not as loyal to you, and the rates keep increasing where new policies they tend to have lower rates. So if something happens, don't be afraid to shop it around.
I always recommend if you can go to an agent instead of online because a lot of the things we talked about, like breed exclusions and things, when you go down a bunch of electronic forms on a website for one of the major insurance companies, they're pre-selecting a lot of options to give you the least coverage for the least premium because a lot of people just shop for the number. So you've got to be careful about that.
22:54 | HOA Rules and Restrictions
Amy Castro 22:54
Okay. Yeah. So what happens if you live in which many as I don't now, but I did for the longest time, live in a homeowner's association and you have a bite incident.
Jason Plotkin 23:05
That's very important to cover here because a lot of us do live in HOAs, and HOAs are great for certain things, very unforgiving for other things. A lot of times you're on the losing end of a battle with them because there's bylaws, there's a lot of rules that you have to follow. And one of those is going to be not as much about dog bites, but probably about dog breeds. I haven't seen one, but they could have something about if you have a dog that bites, you've got to report it.
But a lot of times it's going to be excluded breeds in a community. That's something that's very important because what you don't want to do is risk violating a HOA rule and get put on notice, ignore it, and then have whatever fines they have adding up. And typically you're also going to have to pay their attorney fees if they come after you for it. So it's one of those things where you can't put your head in the sand. You want to be very cognizant of it.
And if you rent in a place that has an HOA, you're still probably going to be liable too. Your lease probably says you have to abide by these rules. They're probably attached or given to you in some manner. It can get a little gray, especially the longer you live somewhere. But you got to make sure you pay attention to it. Yeah. You don't want to be personally responsible. So I that's a great point because we field regular calls of people upset about their HOA.
And a lot of times it's very hard to get out of those fees and they escalate quickly and they're unforgiving.
Amy Castro 24:21
Yeah. They can take the case pretty far. Oh, yeah.
Jason Plotkin 24:25
And they can have a lien against when you go to sell the property. Exactly.
24:29 | Two Key Steps to Protect Yourself
Amy Castro 24:29
Okay. So to pull this all together, because we've talked about a lot of different things, the bottom line is to know what the rules are, where you live, know your pet, whether it's their breed and propensity or past behavior as much as you can, and take reasonable precautions to keep everybody safe. Any other final thoughts on this idea of dog bites keeping everybody safe?
Jason Plotkin 24:52
Just the rehammer two things. One is making sure you understand your insurance policy, what's covered, and then reporting a claim. Don't ignore a letter that you get. get because what happens is sometimes on the law firm side, if people ignore letters, we eventually have to unfortunately file a lawsuit just to get their attention. And we don't want to, especially if it's not much of a case. But somebody was injured, they have some medical bills, they need help, they can't afford them.
If they would have answered it and turned it over to their insurance, it would have been a nothing burger.
Amy Castro 25:19
Yeah.
Jason Plotkin 25:19
But because they ignore the letters, we have to go file a lawsuit, and then what's going to happen is there's a chance their insurance company's gonna say, Well, you never told us about it. You got all these letters, and they're gonna disclaim coverage. So there's always that risk. So understanding your insurance and reporting insurance are two very, very important things.
25:36 | Jason’s Childhood Bite Story and His Book
Amy Castro 25:36
Yeah. Do the right thing up front and you'll be a lot better off in the long run for sure. So beyond your work as an attorney, you have a lot of personal experience with dog bites. I understand you also have written a book to help kids who have been through that similar experience.
Jason Plotkin 25:53
Sure. Yeah, right. Well, I'm a personal injury lawyer, and we represent a lot of children that have been bitten by dogs. I was bitten as a child. It was my parents' anniversary. They went to a nice restaurant. It was their big night out every year. I was at my aunt's house having a sleepover. She had some pickles. I was eating a pickle. And her black Lab, Beau, I used to play with Beau all the time, great dog, decided he liked pickles too. And I'm sitting there in the kitchen, I'm going to bite a pickle.
He goes to bite the pickle, and he gets my lip. So I get it in the face, and lips bleed a lot. So there's a lot of blood. It's much scarier than it actually is, especially for my aunt at that point. I think it might have been more traumatic the first few moments for her because she sees me bleeding, trying to see what's going on and how bad it is. But that made some apprehension about being around dogs afterwards.
So I kind of opened up to that personal experience to some of my clients, to their parents, to walk them through what happened to me. And hey, it gets better. Right. Just that kind of that hope is very important. And then that's when I kind of came up with inspiration. I've never written a children's book. Maybe I could tell this story in a way that could help children after the fact. This is not like a preventative book. This is right here. It's The Pickle, the Patch, and the Puppy.
It's a story for kids who got scared by a dog. So what it really is is a roadmap to be brave again. Children don't always understand how to articulate what's wrong with them. So we came up with the concept, the brain alarm. This alarm happens when going to my aunt's house and she's got a dog and I get a little nervous around it. Or I'm starting to walk on the other side of the street to avoid my neighbor's house that has a dog. The next step is bravery ladder.
And the idea there is children need to slowly get reintroduced to animals and to dogs. And it also brings home the point to parents that children react how adults react. So if something happens and you freak out every time you see a dog, your child's going to freak out. So I wrote it for kids, but it's also really for parents that kind of work on together that you know they're reflective of you. And we gamify it a little bit so each rung on the ladder gets a certificate.
And if you go to there's a website, pickleinthepuppy.com, and for free people can download these certificates and a journal so that children can keep track of each thing they're doing to be brave. And then you get a big certificate at the end that says you you certified the course. And the goal is to have more kids be like me. Because at the end of the book, spoiler alert, I got a puppy. Right? So it was all about working me up to get a puppy, which was my black lab.
And so it's really about just helping kids get back to being around dogs. Yeah. And adults can use it as well. I've had a couple adults who said they love it. And I knew we really hit something special when I started sharing it with therapists. And you go to the website, we got a ton of reviews from therapists. They love it, they're using it a lot outside of just animal bites. It's just teaching kids that overcome anything to be brave.
Amy Castro 28:44
Yeah. Well, and I think it would be helpful too. I know one of the things that I run into in rescue is the parent wants to get a dog for their kids, but then they bring the kids in to meet the dog, and often there's one who's just terrified of the dog. And nothing that even if the dog is doing nothing, they don't want to touch it, they don't want to pet it, they don't want it near it.
And I would think, you know, even for a child that hasn't been bitten to kind of work through that progression of moving towards braveness, exposure, you know, whatever it might need to be. And instead of trying to push it, because I think people try to push it. Like I've I've turned down many people, it's like, no, you can't adopt this dog and take it home. Your kid's obviously terrified of it. Like, how's that gonna work out? You know, not probably not a great idea.
So I like that it can be a resource for a lot of different things. Yeah. All right. Well, Jason, thank you so much for sharing all this incredibly helpful information about keeping people safe and keeping our dog safe as well when it comes to dog bites, and also for sharing the information about the book. This is probably gonna help a lot of people hopefully avoid problems with their dog.
Jason Plotkin 29:50
Well, thank you for having me, Amy. I've loved our conversation. feel free to reach out if you have any follow-up questions.
29:55 | Final Takeaways and Resources
Amy Castro 29:55
Okay, I will. Thanks again to Jason for joining me and sharing not only his legal expertise, but his personal experience with dog bites. If there's one thing I hope you take away from today's conversation, it's that you don't want to wait until your dog bites someone to find out what your insurance policy actually covers. And even if your dog has never bitten anyone, it's worth checking your policy right now.
I'll have links to Jason's book, The Pickle, the Patch and the Puppy, as well as his website and other resources in the show notes. And finally, if you know someone with a dog, text them this episode right now because knowing what to do before something happens could save them a lot of heartache, money, and maybe even protect their dog's future. Thanks for listening to the Pet Parent Hotline. If you enjoyed the show, text a friend right now and tell them I've got a show that you need to hear.
And remember, your pet's best life starts with you living yours. So take good care of yourself this week and your pets.
Apple Podcasts
Castro
RSS Feed
YouTube
Amazon Music
Spotify